Samuel Coleridge-Taylor: Piano Quintet, Fantasiestücke, Clarinet Quintet; Catalyst Quartet, Stewart Goodyear, Anthony McGill; Azica Records
Reviewed by Robert Hugill on 2 March 2021 Star rating: 4.0 (★★★★)
A young American ensemble explores the chamber music of Samuel Coleridge-Taylor, works whose sophistication belies their early date
The music of Samuel Coleridge-Taylor still remains relatively unknown. Despite his early death, his opus numbers reach 83, not to mention the works without opus number, and though Coleridge-Taylor's music is recorded, it is not explored enough by ensembles. Which makes a new project from the Catalyst Quartet highly recommendable. The American ensemble has launched Uncovered, a recording series devoted to artists overlooked in classical music, especially because of their race or gender. The first volume is devoted to early chamber music by Samuel Coleridge-Taylor, with music by Florence Pike, Coleridge-Taylor Perkinson, William Grant Still, and George Walker to come on further volumes.
On Azica Records, UNCOVERED Volume 1 from the Catalyst Quartet (Karla Donehew Perez, Jessie Montgomery, Paul Laraia, Karlos Rodriguez), Stewart Goodyear (piano) and Anthony McGill (clarinet) features Samuel Coleridge-Taylor's Piano Quintet in G minor, Op. 1 (1893), Fantasiestücke Op. 5 (1895) and Quintet in F sharp minor for Clarinet and Strings, Op. 10 (1895).
Coleridge-Taylor was talented young, he started at the Royal College of Music in 1890 (age 15) as a violin student, and after two years focused on piano and composition. He studied composition with Sir Charles Villiers Stanford, who regarded Coleridge-Taylor as one of his two most brilliant pupils (which is saying something considering the luminaries of 20th-century British music who passed through Stanford's study door), the other named by Stanford was William Hurlstone who died in 1906. The works on this disc all date from the period when Coleridge-Taylor was at the RCM, but that does not make them negligible student works, far from it. And whatever Stanford's views on race (and we have no reason to think him any less prone to prejudice than his contemporaries), his attitude to Coleridge-Taylor suggests that Stanford saw his talent not his skin colour.
Brahms is inevitably a major influence, not only does Coleridge-Taylor seem to have admired the composer but Stanford's own training was Germanic and Brahmsian. However, Stanford's genius as a teacher seems to have been to encourage young composers to be something of themselves and his pupils are a varied bunch. The last work on the disc is the best known, the Clarinet Quintet which was written as a result of Stanford's challenge to his pupils, that after the Brahms' Clarinet Quintet (written in 1891) it was impossible to write a piece which did not show Brahms' influence. Coleridge-Taylor managed it, Stanford's comment being 'you’ve done it, me boy!'. But other influences are at work too, and throughout the disc we hear Coleridge-Taylor's love of the chamber music of Dvorak.
At this stage of his career, Coleridge-Taylor was not using African themes in his music (he would start exploring his African heritage after hearing the spirituals of the African-American Fisk Jubilee Singers who had recently toured England, and meeting the African-American poet Paul Laurence Dunbar. But in the Clarinet Quintet, Coleridge-Tayloris already using striking melodic and rhythmic material, and then weaving it into the structure of the piece in much the same way that mature Dvorak weaves Czech melodies and rhythms into his chamber music.
The disc starts with the Piano Quintet from 1893, written for a public recital that Coleridge-Taylor gave in Croydon where he and fellow students performed a programme which included three of Coleridge-Taylor's works including this Piano Quintet. It was probably then unperformed for 100 years, though the composer re-used some of its themes. The opening movement begins with what can only be termed a very Brahmsian sweep to it and it is worth bearing in mind that in 1893, Brahms was still only 60 and had recently written the group of late chamber works including the Clarinet Quintet. This was still new music, though admitedly nowhere near cutting edge. The slow movement is based around a lovely cello theme, whilst the Scherzo is robust in a way which evokes both Brahms and Dvorak. And it is the influence of Dvorak that seems to point the way forward with the fascinating Allegro molto finale, which promises much. One point worth noting, unlike Brahms, Coleridge-Taylor does not over-write his piano parts, this quintet is not a piano-concerto manqué.
The Fantasiestücke come from two years later, when the composer was twenty and were premiered at the Royal College of Music. A set of five pieces, each in their way quite substantial, the title gives a nod to Schumann, who was fond of using it, and they are a group of character pieces, each different in mood. The sophistication of Coleridge-Taylor's use of mood and character, his deft writing for the four strings, is very impressive here. We can hear the influence of Brahms (a bit) and Dvorak (a lot), but also a sense of the composer's own voice.
Finally comes the Clarinet Quintet, and as soon as it starts we can hear the change in mood and style. This is music which is confidently itself, and with hindsight we can hear English music in there too. As I have said, the way that Coleridge-Taylor writes is indebted to Dvorak, but the material he weaves is very much his own. There are many fascinating hints in the slow movement, perhaps a dash of Dvorak's New World Symphony, itself with its disputed links to African-American music, but what is in no doubt is the beauty of the music and Coleridge-Taylor's deft grasp of textures. Again this isn't a concerto manqué, all five instruments weave themselves together. The Scherzo certainly seems emphasise the originality of the piece, we can perhaps imply a debt to Dvorak in the use of rhythms but the sound-world is the composer's own. The perky tune which opens the finale has real folk/traditional roots in its style, a nod to the way composers throughout the 18th and 19th centuries used popular tunes for the basis of finales.
This is not the first time any of these works have been on disc, and the Piano Quintet and Clarinet Quintet are available together on a fine disc from the Nash Ensemble on Hyperion. But this new disc brings a welcome fresh perspective, a young American ensemble perhaps hearing and seeing things in the music which bring out suggestions of Coleridge-Taylor's other influences. And the quartet is joined by two very fine soloists in pianist Stewart Goodyear and clarinettist Anthony McGill. If you have not yet explored Coleridge-Taylor's chamber music yet, or even if you have, this is a lovely disc to try.
Samuel Coleridge-Taylor (1875-1912) - Piano Quintet in G minor, Op. 1 (1893)
Samuel Coleridge-Taylor - Fantasiestücke Op. 5 (1895)
Samuel Coleridge-Taylor - Quintet in F sharp minor for Clarinet and Strings, Op. 10 (1895)
Catalyst Quartet (Karla Donehew Perez, Jessie Montgomery, Paul Laraia, Karlos Rodriguez)
Stewart Goodyear (piano)
Anthony McGill (clarinet)
Recorded at Sauder Concert Hall at Goshen College, Indiana, USA, 28-30 July 2019
AZICA RECORDS ACD-71336 1CD [78:11]
The blog is free, but I'd be delighted if you were to show your appreciation by buying me a coffee.
Elsewhere on this blog
A Musical Zoo:Ashley Riches and Joseph Middleton's delightfully wide-ranging recital on Chandos - CD review
Winter into Spring: Oxford Lieder Festival's Spring weekend concludes - concert review
La La Hö Hö: Sixteenth-century viol music for the richest man in the world from The Linarol Consort - CD review
To delight the eyes and ears without the risk of sinning against reason or common sense: the creation of Reform Opera - feature
What would Bach do? Guitarist Yuri Liberzon on recording the Sonatas for Unaccompanied Violin in transcriptions by his teacher Manuel Barrueco - interview
An engaging surprise: written for the Portuguese court, Pedro Antonio Avondano's Il mondo della luna receives its first recording - CD review
Challenging and surprising: on arb, clarinet and bassoon duo, Zachary Good and Ben Roidl-Ward explore multiphonics - CD review
I wonder as I wander: baritone James Newby in a stunning debut recital with pianist Joseph Middleton - CD review
Beyond Solidarity: Composer and Ivors Academy board member Daniel Kidane talks frankly about 2020 and a watershed moment for diversity in music - feature
To cope with the complexity of modern experience: composer Alastair White discusses the striking philosophical underlay of his opera ROBE, which is receiving its premiere recording - interview
A celebration of the art of transcription: Visions of Childhood from Kenneth Woods, English Symphony Orchestra and soprano April Fredrick - CD review
A reflection of a lifetime's performing: Benjamin Britten's complete folk-songs for voice and piano in a new recording from Mark Milhofer and Marco Scolastra - CD review